Cult Favorite vs. New Release - Too Faced Mascara Close-Up Comparison

Hi everyone! 
I was lucky enough to receive the #MyMascara tester bag from PrismPop!
So for this video, I'm demonstrating not one, but TWO,  super hyped mascaras from Too Faced!
They are...
1. Better Than Sex Mascara FULL-SIZE
2. Damn Girl! 24 Hour Mascara travel-size
The mascaras are part of the Volumptuous Volume & Shamelessly Thick Mascara Set.

First, I used the Too Faced "Better Than Sex" Mascara. This is raved about all over the internet and was the darling of the Too Faced brand until they introduced "Damn Girl!" in June of 2019.

Next, I used Too Faced "Damn Girl!" Mascara, which is reportedly a spongier brush and a pigment with two different shades... 

To be honest, both lash brushes seemed the same to me! And I could not really tell the difference between using one over the other, but I definitely saw the volume and length that both mascaras gave my lashes!! You can definitely see a difference between both Before & Afters! 
I was hoping to pick a winner between the two but it looks like these sisters are closer to twins! 👯‍♀️

Did you see a difference? Let me know which one looked best down in the comments, or which you'd like to try! 
Song: “Sweet” by Liqwyd

All comments (68)

Sign In to comment

  • Erica

    Looks amazing!

  • Marianella Queiruga

    Great video! You just convinced me to try both of these mascaras!

  • Jacquelyn Sneed

    I have both and though they are both nice I love the Damn Girl one the best.

  • Stacey Inocencio

    I have very small thin lashes so I think that the Too Faced Better then Sex would so work on my eyes!!! I really like that you shed one eye plain so we really got an idea how it actually works. The other one is ok - don't like the shape of the brush much though.

  • Angela John

    A good quality mascara is hard to come by. One that really hits all the lashes yet does not clump.

  • Kristine Terry

    I love the better than sex, but I am fed going to have to pick up the Damn Girl, it looks really good, my barely there lashes need that extra help 😂

  • Rita Whirls

    Nice look. Great review and information. I want to try these products.

  • Bonita kasee

    I think the dam girl, gave your lashes more definition, plus length, but did it smear or smudge, within the 24 hour period? I haven't tried it, but would love to

  • Christian Brown

    I love how both mascaras look!! I love how both mascaras looked like they lengthened the lashes. I could see myself using both of these mascaras and the mascara wands look great too.

  • Rose Katz

    🌺🌺These look so pretty. These both look amazing. Your lashes look so long and gives them tons of volume. Thanks for the great video! 🌺🌺

  • Monique

    Nice close up on your mascara application!! I can’t wait to try the Damn girl!!

  • Skylar Carney

    Better then sex mascara just gives me life honestly.

  • Lila

    I have the better than love mascara and it is truly one of the best!

  • Christine Czaiczynski

    Liked the video and I agree, sometimes you can't tell the difference between mascaras so as long as they do what you expect them to go for the less expensive one if it does the same thing and save some money.

  • Tiffany Yuen

    Great video!! ✨Your lashes are amazing with or without mascara 🥰! I’m jealous! Mine are short and unremarkable with or without the best mascara in the world! #lostcause 🤪 I think the Too Faced Damn Girl 24 Hour Mascara actually made a bigger impact than the Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara! 🤔 That being said, the wand on the Damn Girl Mascara is intimidating, and I’d probably opt for the Better Than Sex Mascara, mostly due to fear! Did you have any raccoon eye problems with either of these products? Before the pandemic started, I tried out the Better Than Sex mascara via a tester, and it performed pretty well for the first few hours but raccooned a lot if I sweat at all! Did you have this issue with either product?

  • Marlena Fannin

    I loved how long and thick you= lashes turned out. I have such thin lashes I would love to try either one. My idea of a glam makeup would be mascara and shadow with no liner but full makeup. Thanks for sharing.

  • Deanna Straub

    Either product makes your lashes so much longer. I do think the Damn Girl brush is bigger and thicker looking. Great video. You really got an amazing close up application with both products. Great post. Your eyes remind me of doe eyes, another natural beauty.

  • Lilly

    Both of them are so good and similar! I think I like the second one slightly better, but it's really hard to find a difference. I love the packaging, and the mascara seems to work very well and complements your lashes and eyes!

  • Misty White

    Soft Glam is a subtle look instead of the bold darker makeup and flashy clothes. A lot of new colors. Soft colors. Clothes that are of the norm

  • Rukhsana

    soft glam means to me, light coverage concealer blended all over the face with or without tinted moisturizer. liquid contour bronzor, iguid blush and liquid highlighter, heavy loaded mascara and nude lipstick. i would use the chantacalle mascara as its the best at lenghtening, darkening, curling and volumizing, it also has peptides for longer thicker lash growth.

  • Pauline

    I like both video demo for this mascara comparison. I chose Two Faced Damned Girl in the pink package. Thanks for helping us decide just what's what. Want to hit like for this review.

  • Tonilynn Rosario

    Wow those 2 mascaras look wonderful. I would use the better than sex mascara I have been dying to try.

  • haku izunami

    Thank you girl for giving us such a detailed side by side between both of these favorites! Not gonna lie they do both look beautiful! My personal favorite is of course better than sex! Though to be fair I havent tried damn girl. So I cant give a fair opinion.

  • Nancy Shadowens

    Both look beautiful! I've tried their Better than Sex mascara I liked it . I will have to try the Damn Girl nexr. . I am really loving the essence Lash princess false effect.