The Best Pencil Eyeliner Found at Target

Hi PrismPop, I’m Crystal and today I’m going to be using Pacifica's Natural Eye Pencil in the color “Jet.”

This is just a simple, wooden eye pencil. I’ll need a pencil sharpener to sharpen this!

 It doesn’t drag but it doesn’t exactly glide on like gel or liquid either. But overall, it was pretty easy to use and is very pigmented (unlike some cheap eye pencils). 

 It is 100% vegan, cruelty-free and it’s also waterproof so it will last all day long! 


Let me know what your favorite eye pencils are in the comments down below! 


All comments (132)

Sign In to comment

  • Pauline

    Jet liner looks good on. Thanks for this video.

  • Kathleen Cadigan

    It's 100% vegan

  • Sidney Dale

    Thank you for this great quick review and video! I love that you mentioned how it goes on (easy but not TOO easy/gooey), as well as mentioning the severity of the pigment. So many inexpensive eye pencils just have NO pigment, and leave you dragging and dragging it across your eye only to make it irriated and not get anywhere. Very relatable review, thanks so much!

  • Lindsay Piggott

    i have not found a favorite eye pencil yet this may be it . i wanna try

  • Kristen

    I Have been faithful to the rimmel scandolous eye waterproof gel one but this look great!! Thanks now I have to go to target 😐

  • Katy Gutridge

    O wow I didn’t know they make waterproof pencil eyeliners, my mind is seriously blown right now. That’s amazing that’s it’s vegan and cruelty free very great that companies do that still also I will be needing to try this now!!! Thanks for your video💕

  • Nicole

    This liner looks amazing! I do the wing daily and I’m constantly looking for the perfect liner

  • Crystal Jones

    This liner looks amazing!!I love how natural it looks!I also love that its waterproof and from Target so its easy to find.

  • Misty

    I wear mainly eyeliner. I use to be addicted to these kind. Love pencil eyeliners. They seem to last so much longer. Guess what I need to try. Thanks for the video!


    I prefer pencil eyeliners, I'm a little shaky, I'm definitely giving this one a try!

  • Sary

    That looks great on you! I've had a bit of a phobia of pencil eyeliners since my formative makeup years due to low quality pencils and my amazing ability to injure myself doing the simplest of tasks. (So many eye pokes!) I prefer mechanical eyeliner (fewer pokes, lol) and somewhat thicker, more dramatic looks. It HAS to be waterproof though! Otherwise my sassy, smudgy look turns into my awkward, spidery goth phase real fast.

  • Elly

    Don't have a favorite eyeliner but I want to try this one now.

  • Gilda Gonzalez

    Sweet! I'm definitely going to grab one next time I'm there

  • Jenie Martin

    I wear pencil eyeliner everyday

  • Angela Martin

    I prefer a liquid pen eyeliner. I go between a dramatic and subtle look. I change my look based on my mood or feelings.

  • Kimberly Self

    Pen liner looks fab on you! I like using a pen then to smudge it out. Looks great!

  • Denise Carver

    My ultimate preference is a liquid liner in pen form...I need that control! Occassionally I like a stick liner with the smudge tip!

  • Micheala

    I Love to try this

  • Meaghan

    I have to use pencil eyeliner, liquid is too messy. And I like to use jet black so I might give this a try! 😍

  • Crystal Smoot

    Pencil in subtle or black...soft.

  • Jenn H

    I like a soft pencil or Kohl eyeliner.... though I’ve recently been trying out a liquid. I prefer the lines I get with a pencil but it might be due to more practice. I like a fairly simple look, with the top lid and waterline both in a darker shade.

  • Kimberly Pfeifer

    I love eyeliner! I wear mine daily! ❤ I prefer the pencil on the eyelid!🤗😎

  • katherine wu

    I love liquid eyeliner, it is a lot easier to apply in my opinion. I also think a winged eyeliner look is super pretty!

  • Ronalee Swanson

    I prefer to use pencil eyeliner. I like the simple subtle look that it gives me. I find that my lines are straighter and I'm able to line my lower lashes easier with a pencil. Love the way my eyes pop.

  • Brianna Newbould

    I prefer pencil!

Shop Products Mentioned Above